top of page
Search

The Election Watchdog Has Gone Dark

24 minutes ago
5 min read

By Eric Valcarce '27


The 2026 midterms have come to a close. An estimated $11.6 billion was spent this cycle, the most expensive midterm in American history. (1) During the entire period, the Federal Election Commission, the agency responsible for enforcing campaign finance law, has been shut down. The FEC has had no quorum and no enforcement capacity for over 17 months. It currently has two commissioners out of six. Under federal law, the FEC requires four of six commissioners to take any action.


In February 2026, President Donald Trump put forth two nominations for the FEC, but the Senate has not acted on them, prioritizing other legislative priorities under Trump such as the SAVE America Act. The FEC remains unable to police this election. Its paralysis is not just political bureaucracy. It is the byproduct of a flawed design, one that has always been one bad appointment away from failure, and the current crisis is the most consequential in the agency's fifty-year history.


A Watchdog Built to Fail


Congress first created the FEC in 1974 under the Federal Election Campaign Act (FECA) after the controversies from the Watergate scandal. (2) Under FECA, it established six-year terms for commissioners, requiring a vote of four out of six commissioners to make decisions on substantive actions. FECA also allowed commissioners to hold over: to serve their term indefinitely after the six-year terms have expired. The way the act was designed makes the FEC composition permanently hostage to presidential and Senate action. 


FECA also requires that no more than three commissioners come from the same party, requiring bipartisanship to reach a coalition vote. This rule forces and prevents the weaponization of enforcement against political opponents. (3) However, a structural issue begins to form: if you drop below four commissioners for any reason, the entire agency shuts down. No investigations, no fines, no new rules, no guidance under the FEC. 


There are also constitutional constraints. In Buckley v. Valeo, the Supreme Court held that since FEC commissioners hold significant federal authority, this made them officers of the United States under the Appointment Clause of Article II. (4) In the original language of FECA, Congress had originally let members of Congress appoint four of the six commissioners. The Court struck that down. After Buckley v. Valeo, every commissioner must be nominated by the president and confirmed by the Senate. That means any reforms, including filling vacancies, must go through the same presidential and Senate process that allowed this crisis to develop. 


How the Current Crisis Unfolded


On January 20, 2025, Commissioner Sean Cooksey resigned in order to join JD Vance as counsel, leaving the quorum at five. (5) Nearly a month later, on February 6, 2025, Trump proceeded to fire democratic commissioner Ellen Weintraub, an unprecedented move which she immediately challenged in the federal courts. (6) Her legal basis was Humphrey’s Executor v. United States, which held that commissioners of independent multi-member agencies cannot be removed without cause. (7)


On April 30, 2025, Commissioner Allen Dickerson decided to resign, causing the quorum to be lost and the agency to shut down. (8) Months later, Commissioner Trainor, on October 3, 2025, decided to resign, leaving two democratic commissioners, the first time in FEC history. In February 2026, Trump decided to push forth two republican commissioner nominees, trying to bring back the FEC quorum. (9) However, soon after senators did not focus on the commissioners' nominations, instead prioritizing under Trump to focus on bills such as the SAVE America Act. (10)


What the Agency Can No Longer Do


Since the agency has been shut down, it can no longer open investigations, levy fines, issue advisory opinions, hold hearings, or conduct audits. (11) As of October 2026, there are 307 cases in backlog at the FEC, up from 154 a year earlier, with some investigations dating to the 2022 midterms now approaching the five-year statute of limitations. (12)


Since the recent Supreme Court decision, NRSC v. FEC, the FEC has been unable to issue any guidance on the ruling. (13) The coordinated party expenditure limits have been law since 1974. After NRSC v. FEC, parties can now spend unlimited amounts of funds in direct coordination with candidates. The ruling has now created ambiguity on joint fundraising committees, earmarking rules, and what "coordination" means. Campaigns are currently operating in the dark without FEC guidance. 


This has now left enforcement with the judiciary and state-level authorities, leaving an inconsistent framework of legal enforcement. (14) Currently, criminal DOJ enforcement still functions, but criminal prosecutions are rare and are pursued only if they are a “knowing and willful” violation. (15) The FEC shutdown now leaves it as a “watchdog without a bark or bite”. (16)


The Fix that Never Came


The most expensive election in history is unfolding with no enforcement oversight. The FEC’s paralysis has left a gap in the law that billions of dollars are already flowing through.


There has been a bipartisan push for legislation to reform the FEC. The Restoring Integrity to America’s Elections Act (RIAEA) would decrease the number of commissioners from six to five, allowing each party to have only two affiliated members, with the fifth member being independent. (17) The current six-member structure guarantees deadlock. It requires four votes but caps each party at three commissioners, so a partisan split always produces a 3-3 tie. The RIAEA breaks that by making the fifth commissioner politically unaffiliated, creating a deciding vote no party can block alone. 


The FEC has lost its quorum four times in the past 50 years. The current shutdown is the longest and most consequential. It has lasted through a Supreme Court ruling that rewrote coordination law, a record-breaking spending cycle, and 307 unresolved enforcement cases. The RIAEA would fix the structure of the FEC. The nominees can be confirmed by the Senate to restore the quorum. Until the political will matches the structural problem, the FEC will remain dark, and the money will keep moving. 


Endnotes

  1. Campaigns & Elections, “2026 Midterms Will Be the Most Expensive Cycle Ever,” https://campaignsandelections.com/industry-news/2026-midterms-will-be-the-most-expensive-cycle-ever/.

  2. Federal Election Campaign Act of 1971, 52 U.S.C. § 30106(c).

  3. Congressional Research Service, The Federal Election Commission: Overview and Selected Issues for Congress, R45160, https://www.congress.gov/crs-product/R45160.

  4. Buckley v. Valeo, 424 U.S. 1 (1976).

  5. The Hill, “Sean Cooksey Resigns from FEC,” https://thehill.com/homenews/campaign/5082926-sean-cooksey-resigns-fec/.

  6. Brennan Center for Justice, “Today the FEC Can’t Enforce Campaign Finance Laws — and That’s Only One of Its Problems,” https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/analysis-opinion/today-fec-cant-enforce-campaign-finance-laws-and-thats-only-one-its.

  7. Humphrey’s Executor v. United States, 295 U.S. 602 (1935).

  8. Yahoo News, “FEC to Lose Quorum After Another Commissioner Resigns,” https://www.yahoo.com/news/fec-lose-quorum-another-commissioner-194056988.html. 

  9. Washington Sun / Notus, “Federal Election Commission Donald Trump Commissioner Nomination Quorum,” https://www.washingtonsun.com/money/federal-election-commission-donald-trump-commissioner-nomination-quorum. 

  10. Washington Sun / Notus, “Federal Election Commission FEC Shutdown Case Backlog,” https://www.washingtonsun.com/money/federal-election-commission-fec-shutdown-case-backlog.

  11. Issue One, “FEC Commissioner’s Resignation Will Defang Nation’s Top Campaign Finance Watchdog,” https://issueone.org/press/fec-commissioners-resignation-will-defang-nations-top-campaign-finance-watchdog/.

  12. CBS News, “FEC Midterm Elections Quorum Campaign Finance Rules,” https://www.cbsnews.com/news/fec-midterm-elections-quorum-campaign-finance-rules/. 

  13. NRSC v. FEC, No. 23-xxx (2026).

  14. News-Articles.net, “FEC Quorum Crisis and Enforcement Paralysis,” https://politics-government.news-articles.net/content/2026/07/13/fec-quorum-crisis-and-enforcement-paralysis.html.

  15. Brennan Center for Justice, “The Justice Department Is Now on the Campaign Finance Beat,” https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/analysis-opinion/justice-department-now-campaign-finance-beat.

  16. Yahoo News, “FEC to Lose Quorum After Another Commissioner Resigns,” https://www.yahoo.com/news/fec-lose-quorum-another-commissioner-194056988.html. 

  17. Restoring Integrity and Reliability in Elections Act, H.R. 160, 119th Cong. (2025).

 
 
 

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn

Florida Undergraduate Law Review 2026 | University of Florida

​

All opinions expressed herein are those of individual authors and are not endorsed by the Florida Undergraduate Law Review or its sponsors. The Florida Undergraduate Law Review is a student-run organization and does not reflect the views of the University of Florida.

bottom of page